By Matt Valentine
The MLB season has reached its halfway point and the 2008 All-Star Game is rapidly approaching. As usual fan voting has determined a majority of the roster and their were some surprising players voted to the team as well as some questionable decisions made by the fan base. I’m going to break down the AL 2008 starting roster and examine the snubs,duds, and studs of the American League All-Star team.
Players selected to the All-Star team that make me think MLB fans are dumb aka DUDS:
1. David Ortiz- People please! Just because he’s Big Papi and he’s been a stud in the past he’s been anything but this year. How in the hell do you vote a guy in whose on the DL anyway? What were people hoping for a miraculous return just in time fore the All-Star game? Second of all, its not like his stats were really worthy of an All-Star selection in the first place. Ortiz is batting just .252 with 13 HR and 43 RBI not exactly All-Star numbers.
2. Derek Jeter- As a Yankee fan this is pure blasphemy, but even I have to admit this should not have been Jeter’s year. I understand that Jeter has a been a perenneial All-Star player for most of his career, but this year should have been the exception. Jeter, much like Ortiz, was voted in based solely on the star power of his name and not his performance. Jeter has never been a power hitter so no one expects serious slugging stats, but he’s always batted at least .300, that is until this season. Jeter is batting just .287 with 2HR and 50 RBI not terrible stats by any stretch of the imagination, but not really an All-Star first half either.
3. Evan Longoria- Granted this guy is an absolute lock to be the AL Rookie of the Year, but are his first half numbers really All-Star worthy or are fans just buying into the hype? Longoria’s numbers are strong he’s batting .281 has 16 HR and 53 RBI, but there were plenty of other players whose stats were better then Longoria’s, (think Aubrey Huff from Baltimore for one). They just don’t have the type of hype surrounding this guy.
Player that makes me think MLB players are dumb:
Jason Varitek: Um, are you serious? Ok, he may be a great team leader and all that jazz, but an All-Star nod for this guy? What’s the matter players can’t read stat line’s because if they could I think they would have gone in a completely different direction. Varitek is batting .220 which is his season high,he has 7 HR and what I have to believe is an all-time record low 28 RBI for a “All-Star” player. To make matter worse, he was batting around .130 for a majority of the first half, which makes me believe that if this guys can get into the All-Star game then Billy Crystal has a decent shot at in 2009. I don’t know why the players chose Varitek, but even he had to admit that it was “embarrassing”. Yea its definitely embarrassing that apparently a majority of MLB players can’t read!
Further reasons why I think MLB fans are dumb aka Snubs:
1. Nick Markakis- Yes he plays for a crappy team and he isn’t a big name player, but he did put up some big-time numbers in the first half of the season and he is one player who I feel should have been on the 2008 All-Star squad. Check out these first half numbers, .302 BA, 14 HR, 50 RBI, 61 RS, 9 SB, hmm…similiar to another guy from Tampa but with a better batting average and more runs scored. Too bad for him there’s no hype surrounding himself or Baltimore this season.
2. Jermaine Dye- Dye is currently second among AL outfielders in OPS and is third in the AL with 20 HR. Oh he also plays for the surprising first place Chicago White Sox. You would think that would be enough for him to make the All-Star squad…sorry Jermaine, not with these fans voting. Then again who would you really replace in this AL outfield because all of them deserve a spot on that roster, but there is a man named David Ortiz who probably shouldn’t have been there in the first place.
3. Brian Roberts- What is this the all Oriole team? All kidding aside though this guy should have been given serious consideration for a roster spot. He’s produced at about the same clip as fellow second baseman Dustin Pedroia and has outproduced other players on the roster like Joe Crede, ok Crede hits for more power but that’s not always what defines a good player. Either way Roberts will have to wait until next year for his shot at the All-Star game.
Tags: All Star Game, American League, Baseball, Ben Sheets, Big Papa, Bronx, CC Sabathia, Cliff Lee, Derek Jeter, Duds, homerun, homerun derby, MLB, National League, New York, Snubs, Studs, Yankee Stadium, Yankees